A Friday Night Email from Your Genetic Counselor: 5 Years Later

There were hundreds of patients and moments that left imprints on me over my 20-year career as a clinical genetic counselor (first in Pediatrics at SUNY Syracuse, and then as the Founder and Director of the Yale Cancer Genetic Counseling Program).  One of those moments occurred 4 years ago today, on June 1, 2012.

One of my many patients was a young woman whose brother, Nate, was diagnosed with advanced colon cancer at age 21.  (Nate’s dad, Larry, shared their poignant story on Father’s Day of this year.)  The family history was filled with generations of early-onset colon cancer and polyps of different types.  The family had already been worked up at a well-known genetics clinic in New York and all of the obvious gene-suspects had been tested, and came up negative.  Nate’s sister had a few polyps, but had never had cancer, and was not the obvious candidate for testing.  The obvious candidate was Nate.

Nate showed up at my office a few weeks later looking like a thin college athlete, rather than a patient with advanced colon cancer.  He had a smile on his face, an easy laugh, and was willing to do anything I asked in search of the mutation in his family.  His goals were clear:  he wanted to help his family members and other families avoid his fate.  He knew that he was living with cancer, and not searching for a cure.  We reviewed all of the genetic tests that had been ordered and then ordered a few more – the rare outliers just then being included on cancer panels.  Nothing.  But I promised Nate we’d keep looking.

I arranged a family study day, and Nate’s family invited relatives from near and far.  The family members all drove to Connecticut, signed consent forms, gave blood samples, and patiently allowed us to examine their skin, their medical records and to ask a million questions.  We studied their DNA.  Nothing.

Nate raised money for our search through the foundation he created, Relentless Against Cancer.   The day he presented us with that check he and I spent the afternoon together, recording a podcast episode, and having photos taken.

Despite the obvious path, I was somehow surprised to learn that Nate died in October 2011, at age 24.  The mission to find an answer, to find the “why?”, now became even more critical.

Several months later, a molecular pathology fellow, James Ziai, was doing a rotation in genetic counseling and was reviewing our “unsolved charts”. I showed him Nate’s case and pedigree.  A few months later James said to me, quietly and in passing, “Hey, I think we found the mutation in Nate’s family.”

James is a quiet, sedate, pathologist.  He was likely unprepared for me to yell, ‘WHAT??!!!  WHAT ??!!!” and start jumping up and down.  He seemed a little surprised when I began crying and pumping him for details.  We agreed that we needed to confirm the result and trace it through the affected family members before releasing details.  I was on poor James like white-on-rice for the next several weeks while he performed that lab work.  Then, late on Friday afternoon, June 1, 2012 he called to give me the “go for it” sign.

I raced home from work to relieve my nanny, feed my 2-year old daughter dinner and put her to bed. I then sent Nate’s dad the following email:

Date: Fri, Jun 1, 2012 at 7:03 PM

Subject: News

To: Larry

Dear Larry,

I hope this e-mail finds you and your family well.

We finally have some results and I think they are significant.  Please let me know when you can talk and how I can best reach you.

Many thanks,

Ellen Matloff

Larry wrote back immediately with his phone number and we spoke minutes later on that Friday night.  Finally, finally, we had an answer.  A GREM1 mutation was responsible for the cancers in the family.  We could now realize Nate’s dream to change the course of history for his family members, and to prevent other families from sharing his fate.  Larry and I both understood the gravity of the situation, and the victory that was won in Nate’s memory and honor.

Four years later and it still makes me cry.  Nate, buddy, we did it!  You did it.  Your family did it.  Thank you.

*Nate’s family has allowed us to share their story.

Zia J, Matloff E, Choi J, Kombo N, Materin M, Bale AE. Defining the polyposis/colorectal cancer phenotype associated with the Ashkenazi GREM1 duplication: Counseling and management recommendations. Genet Res, Camb 2016: 98:1–5.